KSRanked Part 3

The top 10!

Sep 04, 2025

Welcome to day 3. Finally, the wait is over. I will now reveal the official Arken rankings for the ten best Kim Stanley Robinson books. This has been a project of many months and much love. I hope you find at least one book to add to your TBR. At the end of the week I will close out the festivities with one more discussion of this whole journey and my appreciation for Stanley, and then promise to move on to other topics for a bit.

Just so everyone is caught up on the story so far, below is where you may find all my KSR related posts. Enjoy!

Love Letter and Addendum.

Part 1: #29-21

Part 2: #20-11

10: New York 2140 (2017)

Science Fiction, Speculative Fiction, Environmental, Utopian

Awards: John W. Campbell finalist in 2018, 3rd place for Best Science Fiction Novel in 2018 Locus Awards

My first KSR book, and the one I have reread most1. I first heard an interview of Stanley on a political podcast in 2019, and by the time I got around to checking him out it was 2020, I was back at home finishing my degree online during the pandemic. I read NY2140 just as a coincidence the week of a severe storm and tornado warning. It culminated in listening to the last half of the audiobook as the house shook by candlelight with no power. My favorite scene in the book is a big hurricane that causes the characters which have grown closer to fully band together and care for each other and experiencing that with a storm outside was perfect.

Not long after that first listen, I had a second revelation by storm. I will steal what I said in my first Love Letter post because I think Past Paul was onto something:

There is a chapter in 2140 that I always remember clearest. Its about halfway through the book so characters are familiar with each other and starting to form their little group just as a hurricane hits the city. I first read this scene during a tornado watch, listening to the rain and wind strike my parents house with candles for lights and no electricity. The timing for my read was memorable, but more importantly I remember feeling moved by the community and strength of the characters. A few months later, I would remember this scene and have a second wave of feeling as I drove across Florida the day after a hurricane. I was going to visit and help Wesley who went to school on the other side of the state, because they had been hit by the storm worse than I was. Miles went by and the destruction increased, but so did the signs of community and resilience with work crews already clearing the highway, shelters in full operation, and people moving on. At the time, I was studying sociology and doing a lot of pondering on my relationship to my community and country. Never have I felt more patriotic and thankful to be a part of something bigger than looking at the disaster relief efforts. I don’t want to spoil the book, but that is very fitting for it’s vision of America.

So anyway, I like the book. But, what kind of book is it? And why does it deserve to be so high on this list?

NY2140 is a character driven “Comedy of the Commons2” where a large cast of everyday people overcome differences and challenges to form a sense of community and face systemic problems together. All this happens in a grounded view of New York City in the near future after rapid sea-level rise creates an intertidal zone of flooded streets. The premise of the worlds cultural and economic capital being underwater seems apocalyptic, after all the damage has already been done, but the future of the year 2140 is more interesting than that. We did not prevent extreme climate change and we haven’t reversed it, but in Stanley’s future we are firmly on the upswing. Society and the biosphere are finally recovering after the really hard times, and NY2140 offers a look into the continued efforts on local and large scale to continue the good work.

So much is the same and yet with the window of possibility tilted just a little to the good it feels like a utopia. To me, 2140 is an extremely approachable call to action for starting that tilt.

Moments of Being: buried treasure in a sunken city, blimps, bears, finance bros, praxis, and meeting your neighbors.

9: Blue Mars (1996)

Science Fiction, Speculative Fiction, Environmental, Utopian

Awards: Winner of 1997 Hugo Best Novel Award, Winner of 1997 Locus Awards Best Science Fiction Novel, Winner of Prix Ozone (France) Award for Best Science Fiction Novel in 1998, 2nd in 1997 John W. Campbell Award

The first mainline mars book to appear on this list is the last in the trilogy. I think of Blue Mars as a book of extremes. In one of the most ambitious and far reaching sci-fi series of all time this book must go the farthest in the future and resolve the transformation of the red planet and everyone who lives on it. Blue Mars attempts, and usually succeeds on chances than most authors never try. It does miss, but overall I was not disappointed. The flaws simply give more room to ponder and then start a reread.

It would be a crime for me to stop there without mentioning the characters. I love them. Ann and Sax specifically are the two best Stanley has ever written. Their dynamic, and the philosophies they represent are the heart of the series. The magic trick of the whole trilogy lies in the aging treatment which allows much longer lives and for individuals a reader cares about to experience the sweeping history and slow transitions described. Transforming a planet is not easy and no person will remain as they are. I think about it often.

Moments of Being: Saying goodbye, low oxygen ultra-marathons, the biggest brain funk imaginable, and creating a new dawn.

8: Wild Shore (1984)

Science Fiction, Speculative Fiction, Alternate History, Dystopian

Awards: Winner of Locus Awards Best First Novel 1985

I said Three Californias was better than it’s parts but I was speaking about the average. This particular part is extremely good. Wild Shore was the first KSR to be published, and it is clear he was going places from the start. Set in his only true post-apocalypse, Wild Shore follows Henry as he comes of age in the irradiated wilderness of southern California. Who sent the bombs and why is unclear, even decades later. There are black ships patrolling the coast enforcing a quarantine on the ruins. The world is over with no answers and yet life goes on. All the wild things are thriving without America at least.

Henry himself is a great POV, with a strong streak of poetic introspection and appreciation for the surprisingly beautiful world around him. He lives a simple life as a tailor’s son, fishes with the other young men, and tries to charm young women on market days. Henry also seeks to impress oldest man in the village, Tom, who shares stories of the days before the end and his 104 years. However, Henry will be pulled in many directions when his village is contacted by men from down south who rebuild the railway and try to reconnect the land in resistance against the shadowy occupation. He must learn to listen to his own wisdom and find a path in this new world.

As a coming of age story Wild Shore excels with a slower pace and smaller stakes. It all comes down to learning how to live. In that effort, I love Henry but Tom steals the show. The old man is a flood of wit, humor, and great lines. He also first introduces many of the themes KSR explores here and in all California books with a story of encountering himself from a different world and different choices. Although Wild Shore was not written with the idea of it’s sequels, the implications for alternate possibilities abound. Henry, for his part of the thematic work, explores ideology and the ways human thoughts and action shape the world. Wild Shore wants you to think about your choices and the context of your life and make a better world. A surprisingly comforting post apocalypse after all.

Moments of Being: Story time with the best old man to ever do it (his ranking), Shakespeare was the best American, almost drowning before running in the snow, Eye of the World Core small village politics and market gossip.

7: Red Mars (1992)

Science Fiction, Speculative Fiction, Environmental, Utopian

Awards: Winner of Nebula Awards for Best Novel 1994, Winner of BSFA Awards Best Novel 1993, Winner of Ignotus Awards (Spain) Best Foreign Novel 1997, Seiun Awards (Japan) Best Foreign Novel 1999 (tie), 2nd in Locus Awards Science Fiction Novel 1993, Runner-up in John W. Campbell Award 1993

Mars is Stanley’s most famous “pure” Science Fiction endeavor and I think it was what everyone expected to be his legacy, the late impact of Ministry for the Future might change this. With Red Mars, the mars trilogy launches an ambitious, realistic, and fresh blueprint for humanity to become a better version of ourselves. It starts with one hundred scientists, explorers, and idealists landing on Mars and ends in world shaking change as the axis of history shifts. This is just book one.

I made the claim earlier that Mars is home to his strongest characters. This is true and starts in Red Mars. Ann and Nadia are the standouts for book one, but the whole cast is strong both as people and vehicles for ideology and conflict which be unleashed on the new planet. The pace is also noteworthy. Chapter by chapter things can feel slow and deliberate, partially because of frequent heavy scientific details or descriptions of the natural world, but I challenge you to look back just a few chapters and see radical progress. Everything starts here and I felt a strong sense of nostalgia for the first settlement in Burroughs even before the end of the first book.

If I were to pick a single KSR to be adapted for a wider audience, it would be Red Mars. 30 years later, we still need this message and the gradual transformation of a planet with the backdrop of high stakes ideological conflict and politics would make for excellent TV. I want to see the sunrise over Olympus Mons, the first lichen to spread across stone, and the wind moving a thickening atmosphere. I want to be there with Sax and Ann to dream for the future and fight for the present.

Moments of Being: Existing on the precipice, love of the natural world, and playing god.

6: Aurora (2015)

Science Fiction, Speculative Fiction, Space Exploration

Awards: John W. Campbell Award finalist 2016

The last entry fills me with a sense of possibility. Aurora is about being realistic.

The generation ship Aurora, is 180 years into a 200 year mission. Not a single character chose to go to the stars, they were born in flight. No piece of the ship can be replaced, but everything is breaking. Earth solved the climate crisis that motivated the ships launch decades ago and lost interest in their success. Help is two centuries away. It is here that the book starts alongside the final deceleration towards the closest suitable planet (with only a possibility of being habitable). Aurora reads as a gripping space exploration survival story. Even in the best case scenario, making a home away from the solar system would be near impossible and it does not go to plan.

The story is told from the perspective of the ship computer after the head engineer, Devi, asks Ship to document their trip as a narrative not just fact. Ship (an enjoyable narrator that walks a believable line between program and person) picks Devi’s daughter, Freya, to be the central character and window into the life of the final generation born in transit. We follow her through her childhood, adolescence, and everything that comes after arrival in Tau Ceti. The blend of slightly impersonal computer storytelling trying to be and human worked well, and gives the book the feeling of an very readable anthropology or sociological case study.

I won’t spoil anything else, but Aurora is a great read. I think it would be interesting and enjoyable beyond Sci-fi readers just as a very human story, but if you have ever dreamt about exploring the stars I think it is an important book. Aurora made me rethink a lot and I enjoyed the experience way more than the characters do.

Moments of Being: Sailboats in space, human will in the face of an uncaring universe, computer godmother learning to person.

5: Green Mars (1993)

Science Fiction, Speculative Fiction, Environmental, Utopian

Awards: Winner of Hugo Awards best novel 1994, Winner of Locus Awards best Science Fiction novel 1994, Winner of Ignotus Award (Spain) best foreign novel 1998, Winner of Italia (Italy) Awards best international novel 2017

Green Mars is revolutionary and not just because of literal revolutions. In my opinion, it improves on everything the first does. The characters remain themselves but become more and different, thee effects on the planet become self enforcing and beyond control, and Stanley asks the reader to question and consider changes to the basic arrangement of society. Budling utopia is hard, but maybe this time it will be closer. We can always try again even as we cannot go back.

Notably, Green Mars begins the generational storytelling of the series with characters that are born Martians and waves of people looking to escape Earth. Everything is steeped in macro forces that cannot be controlled but may be influenced, and choices that cannot be reversed. The map at the front of the nook already has scars. Ann, as the embodiment of conservation for the “Red Mars” and lone woman standing against the tide of history, feels every change as a tragedy. Sax, as the architect of the terraforming and “Green Mars” movement, is trying using every lever at his disposal. This pair is the central conflict for the series, but the full cast have complicated emotions and paths in the changing world beyond a simple color-coded binary. The scope only ever increases while the character stories sharpen. It is masterful.

Moments of Being: Grieving at the birth of a new world, cozy rover cross country drives, a woman named Phyllis being the root of all evil.

4: The Best of Kim Stanley Robinson (2010)

Short Story Collection

Let me explain the top 4. After a certain point I find it difficult to rank the best of KSR books, so I picked the best of each category of his work to sit here at the top. The brings us to The Best of Kim Stanley Robinson which collects most of his short stories into one volume. It is a great collection, and over the course of this project probably the book I was most surprised by3. In reading his novels, it is easy to see that Stanley pulls frequently from authors and traditions to tell stories in his own style. The Best of Collection however shows that he can write in almost any style.

My favorite stories are “The Blind Geometer” and “The Timpanist Of The Berlin Philharmonic, 1942” which both deserve a highlight.

The Blind Geometer

This story follows a blind mathematician who realizes that people are spying on him. His daily life before that knowledge was already enjoyable and well realized, but after it starts a mini espionage thriller where an everyman shows just how special overcoming disability everyday is. I enjoy his thoughts, and the writing choice Stanley makes to structure his internal monologue. Thoughts are a series of assumptions and premises he deduces from known information in plain text, assumptions on uncertain information given in parenthesis, assumptions that build on those within brackets, and so on. Navigating the world becomes a series of proofs which are challenging and fulfilling on their own. Perfect.

The Timpanist Of The Berlin Philharmonic, 1942

Full reading with an intro from KSR:4

3: The Years of Rice and Salt (2002)

Alternate History, Speculative Fiction

Awards: Winner Locus Awards best Science Fiction novel 2003

I have selected The Years of Rice and Salt as the clear best of KSR’s alternate history and historical work. In Rice and Salt, he asks “what if the bubonic plague wiped out 99% of Europe instead of thirty?” and goes from through over seven hundred years of brilliance. The story is structured into ten “books” showing many lives by a handful of souls stuck in a cycle of reincarnation. Readers can follow the characters across lives by personality traits and the first letter of each name which stay constant. The struggle of the characters against cruel circumstance over and over mirrors the generational fight for progress, equality, and science across centuries and slowly show something beautiful. This is Stanley’s most Buddhist and most feminist book. We read as the macro and personal play out on page with no compromise.

I enjoy the characters, settings, and sheer creativity in this book. I think it is probably his smartest and deepest book. When my family book club read it (they voted for it so don’t blame me) only a few made it through the first week’s section because it is longer and more graphic than what we normally read especially at the start, but everyone that read to the end gained something. For myself, that was the month of book club where I felt like I was running a full literature class. I was challenged by the book and only found more depth the further I looked. I made notes, did research, and came to meetings excited to share and learn from others.

I will leave you with a poem by the Widow Kang:

Two wild geese fly north in the twilight.
One bent lotus droops in the shallows.
Near the end of this existence
Something like anger fills my breast;
A tiger: next time I will hitch it
To my chariot. Then watch me fly.
No more hobbling on these bad feet.
Now there is nothing left to do
But scribble in the dusk and watch with the beloved
Peach blossoms float downstream.
Looking back at all the long years
All that happened this way and that
I think I liked most the rice and the salt.

Moments of Being: War in the bardo and on Earth, marriage as afterlife, searches for meaning, the moral universe bends towards justice.

2: High Sierra A Love Story (2022)

Non-Fiction

Awards: Winner Rosebud Awards Best Non-fiction, Glenn Goldman Award: California Lifestyle in 2022 by the California Independent Booksellers Alliance, Californiana Award in 2023 from the Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California

High Sierra deserves the be at the top of this list, unfortunately I cannot do that. This is the only non-fiction book published by KSR, although he may be working on a companion piece celebrating Antarctica right now. If that book is anywhere as great as High Sierra, I will be very happy.

Through personal stories, poems, and essays Stanley shows the reader his lifelong obsession with the Sierra Nevada mountains. Decades of hiking, activism, and wonder are on full display. The physical book is full of maps, diagrams, and photos but the audiobook is narrated with love by Stanley himself so there is no bad way to read it. The “Moments of Being” phrase I have used throughout my list comes from High Sierra where Stanley describes times and places he was able to fully exist in and appreciate the natural world around him. These experiences define and change us, and are at the root of the calls to action for environmental and social justice High Sierra makes.

I recommend this book to anyone and everyone5. I challenge you to remain unchanged.

Moments of Being: Pushing through bramble, renaming mountains, irreplicable moments with land and people we will miss later.

1: Icehenge (1984)

Science Fiction, Speculative Fiction, Philosophical

Awards: NOTHING.

This is the summit. The peak6. I find Icehenge to be a perfect book and it secures the distinction of best in a career of one of the most impressive active science fiction writers. It was his second book and stands alone or acts as a capstone.

Icehenge is broody. It is efficient. It is dense.

In less than 300 pages, KSR gives a fractured tale that asks fascinating questions and gives even better answers.

Counterintuitively, this was the first Mars book and the start of Stanley’s wider fictional timeline. It takes place at a time when the utopian project on mars has stalled or slipped slightly, when people have spread out into the solar system and must make our own meanings. The aging treatment has extended human lifespans into an uncertain infinity beyond what the human brain can store memories for.

The three POVs each surround the discovery of a massive unnatural monument discovered on Pluto. Each is in conversation with the others with information that builds upon and counteracts those before it. Who made Icehenge? In a world beyond memory, who gains from an unmarked monument? Do it’s creators even know they are responsible? Can truth exist in the age of structural censorship and personal amnesia?

Icehenge is about personal and interplanetary archeology. I have never read any book like it and it is full of imagery and themes that have stuck with me. The central metaphor of the eponymous Icehenge is already perfect. One can never know the truth about the outside world or even yourself, it is all a distortion of something real. Ice (like memory) can be a mirror, a window, or opaque. The monument appears ageless and in it’s time. It changes with perception and labels, but existed alone for an unknown period before discovery. Ice will eventually melt, but can also hold a moment forever.

There is even more to say, but I want to keep as many mysteries unexplored for new readers as I can. Read this book!

Moments of Being: body surfing on a comet, encounters with the sublime, questions without answers.

What’s Next?

There it is. An official ranking. I will return in a few days to finish this project with some final thoughts during the weekend or next week at the latest.

After taking some time to recover, I have a few future KSR related essays planned and will try to sprinkle those in with my regular programing in the next few months. Thank you for going on this journey with me and tolerating my obsession. I hope I was able to at least make some of you interested in KSR or understand why I bring him up so often.

Arken Thoughts

Discussion about this post

Ready for more?